A little over a year ago, I had the privilege of reading Diane Stringam Tolley’s novel, Daughter of Ishmael. I absolutely loved how she used the early stories of Lehi, his family, and the family of Ishmael, to create a beautiful story surrounding a young lady she named Hannah, one of the daughters of Ishmael. Through this novel, the idea opened up to me that the separation of Lehi’s family into righteousness and wickedness may not have been as straightforward as it seemed.
From the last novel, we learn that Hannah, though married to Lemuel, who ultimately chose wickedness, always believed in the words of Lehi and Nephi. At the end of Daughter of Ishmael, she found herself being stoned to death by those who called her family, even her own teenage son, Samuel.
At the beginning of A House Divided, we pick up where we left off, where Hannah, left for dead, miraculously survived her stoning. While reading, my heart ached for her, and I could feel her physical and spiritual pain as she immensely struggled to press forward and journey towards Nephi and his people. The hope that God put inside of her was truly touching, and helped her make that journey despite her immense pain.
Hannah was truly blessed by the Lord in so many ways as she remained faithful and obedient. The first chapters of the novel as she journeyed by faith to Nephi’s camp were my favorite. She had rescued a new friend who would be a protector to her and those she loved for many years to come; she came face to face with others from Laman’s camp – some who would have changed hearts, and some who would have tragic ends to their lives; and she endured much danger, from Laman’s men, to ferocious creatures, to natural disasters.
Finally, she, her furry companion, and Tabitha from Laman’s camp, made it to safety with Nephi and his people, their people.
But if only their struggles ended there. No, there would be much heartache due to deaths of loved ones, both Nephites and Lamanites. You see, though their houses were divided, they were still family. They were still connected. Many in Nephi’s camp mourned for their children and siblings in the Lamanite camp.
Nephi was a strong leader, a true prophet of God for the Nephites. Tolley added scriptural occurrences to the novel, such as the growing industry of the Nephites, the building of the temple, Nephi writing on golden plates, and Jacob assuming a role of spiritual leader as well, teaching them of Christ and a higher law He would bring. See 2 Nephi Chapter 5 (and onward, if you want to read Jacob’s teachings, for more information.
And then, Tolley uses one little verse at the end of chapter 5 to make the second half or her novel:
And it sufficeth me to say that forty years had passed away, and we had already had wars and contentions with our brethren.
At first, the conflicts between the Nephites and Lamanites, leading to their war towards the end of the novel bothered me because there were no scriptural accounts to that affect. But, when I found that verse, I felt better. Obviously most of the novel is fiction, but it gave me comfort knowing that the bones of it resembled the actual history.
There were a few chapters in the novel that I found boring, but once the Lamanites started to cause harm and problems to the people, things got more interesting again (that sounds horrible, I know). The reason I say that is because, once again, you start to feel the fear, anxiety, desperation, and then courage of the people. New characters and old made appearances, and there was much heartache due to the Lamanite actions.
The war between the Nephites and Lamanites in the novel perhaps brought the sweetest, and also saddest part of the novel, at least for dear Hannah. I won’t tell you what it is – just trust me. It has to do with those Hannah holds dear.
I must be honest, and say that there were some things I didn’t like about the novel:
All of the sisters of Ishmael, except Uzziel, had an active part in the novel. It would have been easy to add her in, and I wish that she had been.
Some of the people in Nephi’s camp who were important were barely mentioned or used, such as Sam.
Unless I missed it, there was no curse of darkness put on the Lamanites. That was too important not to be mentioned.
There were a lot of characters in the novel – so many that it was really hard to keep track. A chart at the back of the book would have been very helpful.
Many times in the novel, Hannah was approached about remarrying. I felt that happened too many times and that her decision should have been respected.
What bothered me the most were the impulsive and violent actions of Nephi surrounding evil Lamanite actions concerning his daughter. It felt very out of character for a man who his whole life had always been completely obedient to the Lord, in tune with the Spirit, and completely forgiving of evil.
That being said, it was overall, an amazing novel, and a perfect sequel to Daughter of Ishmael. Just as the first book, this novel really makes you think about the complexity of a family separating, and the heartache, and simultaneous fear and hope that go along with it. I will truly never read the accounts of the early generations of the Nephites and Lamanites the same way again. Thank you for that, Diane Stringam Tolley.
I loved that Hannah gets another book! The last book, Daughter of Ishmael, left us hanging as to Hannah’s fate after she was stoned by her own family. This book starts right where that one left off with Hannah in just as much danger.
I loved Hannah. She is really resourceful and able to take care of herself and those that end up entrusted to her care. I also loved that things weren’t quite as Hannah had thought they were. There were more living in King Laman’s settlement that felt as she did that Nephi was a prophet and that they needed to follow him. There was almost constant danger for Hannah during her travels. From the camp of Laman camping in exactly the same place she was hiding while she recovered, to a bear sighting, to a flash flood. Lots of excitement for her.
I liked that the whole book is from Hannah’s point of view. She really has a unique perspective, because she had been married to Lemuel, she knew how Laman’s camp operates and the lengths they are willing to go to get what they want. But she is a righteous woman, who wanted to follow Nephi, even when her family and everyone around her didn’t.
I really liked the plot of this one. The time period this book covers is significant, over 15 years. The author did a really great job showing the passage of time and not making the book confusing.
If you like historical fiction, and you’ve always wondered what could have been happening during this time period in the Book of Mormon this one’s for you!